This blog contains student opinions and postings about the concepts discussed during their study of biology in this college level course.
Sunday, December 9, 2018
Lava Lamp’ Proteins May Help Cells Cheat Death.
Moskvitch, Katia. “‘Lava Lamp’ Proteins May Help Cells Cheat Death.” Quanta Magazine, Simons Foundation, 26 Nov. 2018, www.quantamagazine.org/phase-separating-proteins-may-protect-and-regulate-cells-20181126/.
In her scientific review, Katia Moskvitch explores the breakthrough discoveries of biophysicist Clifford Brangwynne and his team concerning the existence of liquid-liquid phase separation in cells. Liquid-liquid phase separation is best visualized by the liquid components of a lava lamp which cluster and separate into shifting blobs due to their different densities and incompatible polarities. Recent work in cellular biology suggests that such a phenomenon has been harnessed by evolution to manipulate the metabolism and functioning of cells via proteins in the cytoplasm. Experimentation and imaging indicate that when cells are deprived of nutrients, or otherwise under severe stress through temperature or acidity changes, non membrane-bound metabolic components aggregate and solidify--essentially putting the cell into a hardy condition of stasis. The state change is orchestrated by specific proteins in the cell, whose “identifiable domains” allow the associated cellular matter to shift between its normal fluid state and more gel-like clusters.
This breakthrough has extensive repercussions for the way we study cell functioning and molecular biology. Streamlined through cleanly cut curriculums, the average science student’s understanding of cell anatomy, metabolism, and normal operations is inherently flawed and oversimplified. Investigation of the manipulation of physical phases by proteins in the cytoplasm is just one example of how the scientific community is looking to enrich its understanding of the most basic unit of life through a different lens. Moreover, this discovery has sparked the interest of scientists around the world who are suggesting other fields where protein liquid-liquid phase separation could take place. For example, neuroscientists have posited that vesicle deployment at neurotic synapses may be purposefully delayed by aggregation, effectually controlling the reception of neurotransmitters.
I enjoyed Moskvitch’s article because of her ability to put complex microbiological topics in layman's terms. However, I felt that at times, she avoided scientific jargon to the extent that the specific procedures used by the scientists and the types of proteins involved in aggregation were unclear. Reading this article has left me with many unanswered questions: is aggregation a physical or chemical process and why are specific proteins able to regulate it? What is “the domain” of a protein that determines its ability to regulation phase change? What are the long-term effects of solidifying organelles and proteins and are they able to recover their functions? I look forward to seeing liquid-liquid phase separation explored in future scientific discussions and perhaps in the future, it could be manipulated by humans to treat disseminating diseases by delaying spread between cells.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
In this review, Grace did an excellent job of sumarizing the scientific phenomenon her article was about. Her simple explanation of the principle, liquid-liquid phase separation, in comparison to a lava lamp perfectly illustrated the topic so that it can be understood by anyone. Furthermore, she excellently analyzed the writing in her final paragraph. I was particularly interested by the point she makes of how the authors attempts to simplify the concept at times make it difficult to understand, as often happens in scientific writing. Overall, the review was well written, cleanly organized and beautifully crafted.
ReplyDeleteOne thing I felt the review was lacking is an explanation of how this scientific concept can be useful. The title states that it helps cells "cheat death" but the review lacked a thorough explanation of exactly how this happens. Additionally, I feel some additional quotes or statistics from the original article could have helped support her explanation.
Cells are the fundamental unit of life, and their functions are what keep us alive. BY understanding the functions of cells we can understand more about the human body and how we work. The knowledge that comes from research of cellular principles, such as liquid-liquid phase separation, holds the potential to help us develop more ways to manipulate cells to act desireably. For example, as grace describes, though this process we may be able to manipulate the reception of neurotransmitters.
Michael Grieco
ReplyDeleteAP Biology
Current Event 12 - Comment
December 20, 2018
Moskvitch, Katia. “‘Lava Lamp’ Proteins May Help Cells Cheat Death.” Quanta Magazine,
Simons Foundation, 26 Nov. 2018,
www.quantamagazine.org/phase-separating-proteins-may-protect-and-regulate-cells-201
81126/.
https://bronxvilleapbiology.blogspot.com/2018/12/lava-lamp-proteins-may-help-cells-cheat.html
In her review, Grace composed a comprehensive summary and analysis of her article. She described the topic of her article in a way that anyone could understand. This simple yet complex summary contextualizes the topic, allowing readers to go into the article itself with some context. Additionally, in her second paragraph, Grace emphasizes the implications of the research, showing the reader that this is very important and will have far reaching effects. And finally, her critique of the article is necessary to read the actual article with full comprehension. She talks about the lack of “scientific jargon” and this is important to understanding the new study.
Despite the comprehensiveness of this review, I believe Grace should have included more about the actual process itself. This could help the reader further comprehend what the topic is and how it works. Additionally, she could have included some statistics and quotes from the article that could help the reader understand the context of the article better.
This research regarding cellular function can have far reaching implications in our understanding of living organisms. Through research like this, we can discover more ways to help organisms live longer and to manipulate cells.