Allison Barker
Current Event Review
AP Bio
1/9/17
Hamers, Laurel. "Facial-processing Area of Brain Keeps Growing throughout Childhood." Science News. N.p., 05 Jan. 2017. Web. 09 Jan. 2017. <https://www.sciencenews.org/article/facial-processing-area-brain-keeps-growing-throughout-childhood?tgt=nr>.
I read the article “Facial-Processing Area of Brain Keeps Growing Throughout Childhood” by Laurel Hamers. This article discussed new findings by a team of researchers that indicate that the part of the brain whose function is to recognize faces continues growing new tissue throughout childhood, which is contrary to what scientists previously believed. Brain development during childhood is widely believed to involve pruning back neural connections rather than growing new neural tissue, so this finding is revolutionary. Scientists such as Brad Duchaine, who was not a part of the study, are excited about the prospect of new growth techniques being discovered. Duchaine expressed his joy that “pruning isn’t the only game in town.” In order to gather this information, researchers used magnetic resonance imaging to find the areas of the brain’s visual cortex that work to identify faces and compared those to the areas of the visual cortex that identify images of places. The scientists compared the structures of these two brain areas in the brains of 22 children (aged 5 to 12) and 25 young adults (aged 22 to 28). The collateral sulcus, which identifies places, did not change much between childhood and adulthood, but the fusiform gyrus, which identifies faces, changed dramatically in this time period. The tissue in the fusiform gyrus of adults contains a different composition of cells and proteins and is much denser than that of children. Although scientists cannot determine from the MRI scans the types of cells and structures that result in the increased tissue observed in the fusiform gyrus of adults, but findings from previous studies suggest that the cause could be an increase in dendrites, which are the projections of nerve cells that communicate with other nerve cells. Dendrites might branch out more while the child is growing and make more connections. Another cause could be the oligodendrocytes, which are brain cells that produce the insulating myelin coating that surrounds nerve cells. One thing is for sure, though, according to neuroscientist Jesse Gomez, who led the study: The number of nerve cells is not increasing. This study cannot determine whether brain tissue increases only in the facial recognition area or in other visual areas of the brain, as well, because this study only compared the areas of the brain that recognize faces and places. However, this study does prove that the development of different types of visual processing occurs in different ways. One reason for the development of facial recognition tissue later in life may be the time it takes for humans to develop facial recognition skills. Gomez states, “Throughout development, our social circle grows. That might be one reason why the region continues to grow - that piece of hardware in the brain itself just takes time to develop.” The researchers will continue following their subjects in order to determine the cutoff age for tissue growth, and they hope to investigate the other specialized regions of the visual cortex in later studies in order to see whether similar tissue growth occurs in these areas.
The findings of the study discussed in this article have large implications for humanity. It is a goal of scientists to try to determine how the brain forms because knowing the makeup of the brain, and how it changes over time, could be key in curing many disorders. These findings could especially help in research regarding developmental disorders, as they discovered how a key region in the brain develops. Further, the method of growth for the tissue in the facial-processing region of the visual cortex could also occur in other regions of the visual cortex, so this discovery could advance understanding in research of many parts of the brain. It is imperative to continue learning how the brain works, and it is exciting that scientists have been able to determine a new growth process in the brain.
I found this article very interesting and easy to understand. I do not know much about neurobiology, so I was intimidated when I first saw the article, as I was not sure that I would understand anything. However, the language that the author used was very accessible, and she described the methods, results, and implications of the study very well. The only thing that I would change about this article is the discussion of “pruning.” Pruning is another method of brain tissue growth, and it is the method that scientists had assumed all brain tissue used to develop. Although this is mentioned a couple of times, pruning is never explained. I feel that a discussion of pruning would aid in the understanding of the reader and would allow for greater contrast in the new method of growth that has been discovered. Overall, though, I loved that this piece taught me a great deal about a subject that I was not familiar with.
Charlotte Prior
ReplyDelete1/10/17
Current Event Comment 13
Hamers, Laurel. "Facial-processing Area of Brain Keeps Growing throughout Childhood." Science News. N.p., 05 Jan. 2017. Web. 09 Jan. 2017. .
I read Ali’s review on the article “Facial-Processing Area of Brain Keeps Growing Throughout Childhood” by Laurel Hamers. Ali did a good job on the review, she included great details and the review was lengthy. She also did a good job on teaching the readers about the topics that she learned, she includes terms and explanations for each one. She also did a good job of choosing a topic that is challenging and showed her willingness to learn.
She could have improved on the explanation of why she chose to learn about this topic. Another thing she could have done was expand on the benefits of this technology. Other than these things there really is not much more Ali could improve on.
This was a very well written review, and I learned a lot reading this. I had never heard of this tech before and this review brought it to light in a very interesting way.
Hamers, Laurel. "Facial-processing Area of Brain Keeps Growing throughout Childhood." Science News. N.p., 05 Jan. 2017. Web. 09 Jan. 2017. .
ReplyDeleteAli’s review of Facial-processing Area of Brain Keeps Growing throughout Childhood was a very interesting review. First of all, it really helped that she defined some of the words she used, like collateral sulcus and fusiform gyrus as I had no idea what they meant. In addition, the fact that she stated a scientist’s name and his opinion on this topic, like Brad Duchaine who said that “pruning isn’t the only game in town,” aided me in understanding this topic better and gave me some additional information about it. Furthermore, Ali did a really good job on thoroughly explaining the experiment that was done and she did a good job stressing the ages of the participants. For instance, she stated that the scientists compared the structures of the two brain areas in the brains of 22 children (aged 5 to 12) and 25 young adults (aged 22 to 28). By being very through in her review, Ali showed that she really knew what she was talking about.
Although this review was well written, one way it could have been made better is that Ali could have expanded a bit on the benefits of knowing this new piece of information. So by adding a few sentences about this topic, she could have avoided this problem. Moreover, I really liked how she added one scientist’s opinion but I thought she could have added one more to really make her review detailed. By adding one more quote she could really catch people’s attention.
Overall, this review was captivating and thorough. I had never heard about this research, so I was intrigued when I read Ali’s review. Thus, learning about this was very enlightening and taught me many new things. Reading this review made me realize that science is always changing and we are always learning and discovering new things in many domains. This review really got me to think more about the subject of research and the work scientists do.
ReplyDeleteHamers, Laurel. "Facial-processing Area of Brain Keeps Growing throughout Childhood." Science News. N.p., 05 Jan. 2017. Web. 09 Jan. 2017. .
I read Ali’s review of the article, “Facial-Processing Area of Brain Keeps Growing Throughout Childhood” by Laurel Hamers, which was about the new found information about how the brain continues to grow new tissues throughout childhood in the part of the brain that functions to recognize faces. She discussed the way that the research gathered information for this study through “magnetic resonance imaging to find the areas of the brain’s visual cortex that work to identify faces and compared those to the areas of the visual cortex that identify images of places.” She then goes on to discuss why this is happening and says that it could be due to, “an increase in dendrites, which are the projections of nerve cells that communicate with other nerve cells. Dendrites might branch out more while the child is growing and make more connections.” Finally she tells us that this study has proven that the development of facial recognition occurs in different ways than previously believed. I chose to read Ali’s review of this article because the topic is interesting and it seems like something that could be important to our understanding of the brain.
I think that Ali could have done a better job of explaining certain parts of the study that may be hard for the common reader to understand, since most people only know basic facts about the brain. She also could have explained why this article was chosen and how it impacts the human life.
From reading Ali’s review I learned a lot about the brain that I had not previously known. I never knew that how much our brain was changing during childhood so this gave me a good insight into my actual mind. This review will change my perspective by allowing me to be more aware of what is going on in my brain.
Grace Randall
ReplyDeleteCE 14
Hamers, Laurel. "Facial-processing Area of Brain Keeps Growing throughout Childhood." Science News. N.p., 05 Jan. 2017. Web. 09 Jan. 2017. .
Ali’s review of the article, “Facial-processing Area of Brain Keeps Growing throughout Childhood,” was very well done. Her summary was clear and concise, while still providing a depth of information about this topic. She also incorporated relevant quotes from her article that definitely added to the credibility of her review and helped me understand the information better. For example she included a quote from one of the scientists who gives their opinion that, “pruning isn’t the only game in town.” She also included a thorough explanation of the experiment, including hards facts and numbers. For instance she said “The scientists compared the structures of these two brain areas in the brains of 22 children (aged 5 to 12) and 25 young adults (aged 22 to 28). The collateral sulcus, which identifies places, did not change much between childhood and adulthood, but the fusiform gyrus, which identifies faces, changed dramatically in this time period.” Finally, I thought Ali did an exemplary job giving constructional criticism to the author of this article. She made a very strong point saying “I feel that a discussion of pruning would aid in the understanding of the reader and would allow for greater contrast in the new method of growth that has been discovered.” I would definitely agree with this criticism as I even notoiced it in hr review.
Overall Ali did a good job, but she still could improve a few areas. For example, she could have provided some more quotes from the article to improve her explanation, although she did use one short excerpt. Also, she could have expanded upon certain areas of discussion, specifically the advantages or benefits of this new technology.
I was very interested in Ali’s review and the article she cited. I had brief knowledge about this topic before and was unaware that this was becoming a new type of technology with potential. It reminded me of the power of research and how it changes the field of science every day.
In Ali’s review of “Facial-Processing Area of Brain Keeps Growing Throughout Childhood”, she did a great job of summarizing the the article in a lot of depth. I was able to clearly understand what was discussed in the article. In addition, she did a great job of providing a definition for terms the reader may not understand. For example, she stated that dendrites “are the projections of nerve cells that communicate with other nerve cells.” One more thing Ali did a great job on is including quotes from experts mentioned in the article. This added legitimacy to her review and made me further believe that the information she provided is accurate to the article.
ReplyDeleteOn the other hand, Ali could have improved her review by adding more details as to why she thinks it will affect society. She states that learning new information about the brain could cure many disorders, so I think adding which developmental disorders or how the facial-processing area of the brain is related to developmental disorders would be beneficial. Another thing Ali could add to her review is reasoning as to why she chose this article.
After reading Ali’s review, I learned that the facial-processing area of the brain keeps growing throughout childhood, contrary to what scientists originally believed. I chose to read Ali’s review based on its title. I did not know much about neurobiology, so I thought reading Ali’s review would be very interesting and educational. From now on, I will know that my brain is constantly changing as I have not reached adulthood yet.
Hamers, Laurel. "Facial-processing Area of Brain Keeps Growing throughout Childhood."
Science News. N.p., 05 Jan. 2017. Web. 30 Jan. 2017.
.