Rosner, Hillary. “A Chemist Comes Very Close to a Midas
Touch.” The New York Times. The New
York Times, 15 Oct. 2012. Web 15 Oct. 2012.
<http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/16/science/modern-day-alchemy-has-iron-working-like-platinum.html?ref=science&_r=0>
This
article goes into how Dr. Chirik, 39, is trying to use certain abundant
elements to act as scarce ones, which are expensive and hard to get. At the
beginning, the article leads introducing alchemy. In defining how it is the
science of trying to change elements into others, like lead to gold, it goes
into how Dr. Chirik has managed to achieve this idea, with a twist. Although
not full blown atomically changing the element of iron to platinum, the chemist
is able to essentially wrap an iron molecule in an organic molecule called
ligand. This ligand alters the number of electrons available to form bonds,
making iron act like platinum. The article then goes into how Dr. Chirik’s
process now has to be flexible, in case certain elements that were abundant
become scarce, like with what is happening with cobalt. As explained in the
article, Dr. Chirik was working with cobalt in producing new types of cheap
plastic, but with the cobalt now being highly used in flat batteries for iPads
and iPhones, it has become too scarce and expensive to even work with. The
ending of the article goes talks about how Dr. Chirik first got inspired into
trying to use abundant elements to replace the scarce expensive ones. It even
quotes him talking about a past experience of being extremely careful with a
small amount of Iridium, which costs $16,00 per pound, and wondering why he
cannot just use something cheaper.
This can greatly impact the world, considering this scientific change could alter the economy for the better. As talked about in the article, small amounts of very scarce and expensive elements, such as platinum, are used in making products from jeans to beer. Large amounts of money are spent on elements like these (platinum costs $22,000 per pound) and chemically making a substitute would not keep manufacturing at the same efficiency, but also make it incredibly cheaper. A pound of iron only cost 50 cents, so having it replace something as valuable as platinum will have a strong affect on the global economy for the better, and that is only with one element.
This can greatly impact the world, considering this scientific change could alter the economy for the better. As talked about in the article, small amounts of very scarce and expensive elements, such as platinum, are used in making products from jeans to beer. Large amounts of money are spent on elements like these (platinum costs $22,000 per pound) and chemically making a substitute would not keep manufacturing at the same efficiency, but also make it incredibly cheaper. A pound of iron only cost 50 cents, so having it replace something as valuable as platinum will have a strong affect on the global economy for the better, and that is only with one element.
The
article, although fairly interesting, had a bad set up in my opinion. It kept
on flipping from topic to topic while going back to Dr. Chirik’s progress. It
seemed odd to end the article with Dr. Chirik’s motivation to go into this
alchemy-type of thinking rather than start with it, and the article does not
get to explaining how Dr. Chirik alters iron to act as platinum until halfway
through the article. Lastly, it would have been more interesting to go into the
actual chemistry of how exactly iron now can act like platinum in going through
this process. Other than this, the article was still a great read.