I read the New York
Times article “A Revolutionary Surgery, Now as Typical as a Sinker,”
written by Mike Tierney. In this article, the author talks about how widespread
“Tommy John” surgery has become. He says that it, “…now extends to pitchers at
multiple levels of the game, as well as tennis players and javelin throwers,
from athletes as young as 14 to those nearing retirement.” The surgery grafts a
tendon from the forearm into the elbow to act as a ligament. More and more
people are getting this surgery, including young athletes. While it has most
definitely been beneficial for athletes, there are questions about whether or
not people should get it if their ligament hasn’t been torn. Athletes seem to
think that it makes their elbows stronger, but that could also be attributed to
that fact that they are doing more exercises and getting physical therapy. In
recent years the surgery has been advanced to involve a different way of
grafting and a less invasive procedure.
There
is no doubt that the operation is effective, but should this many people be
getting it? The author said, “…baseball patients were amazed to learn that the
condition was not caused by an improper pitching style. ‘Really, really good
technique increases it the most,’ he said, adding that as players got bigger
and stronger, the need for surgery would only increase.” What does this say
about our society? We are driving people, even kids, to compete in sports that
are rapidly breaking down their bodies and destroying their elbows. It is only
through the discoveries of modern medicine that these people can move their
elbows without severe pain. There is so much pressure on athletes to be
successful that they are ruining their bodies. The question should not be “What
can we do to cut down the recovery time of the procedure?” but “What can we do
to stop the harm done on our bodies in sports?”
I
thought that the author did a good job writing a readable article, but I think
that he touched on too many topics and didn’t go in depth enough on any of
them. I would like to know more details about what the surgery involves, and
what it is about the sports these athletes play that causes the injuries. It
would have been a better article if the author had talked more about the
controversy of the operation, because I believe that there is more to it than
what he mentioned.
Tierney, Mike. "A Revolutionary Surgery, Now as Typical
as a Sinker." The New York Times.
The New York Times, 07 Mar. 2014. Web. 09 Mar. 2014. <http://www.nytimes.com/2014/03/08/sports/baseball/how-tommy-john-surgery- has-evolved-since-frank-jobe.html?ref=science&_r=0>.